Should You Take a Plea Deal? The Pros and Cons of Plea Bargaining in Criminal Defense

July 2023 | By Rusty Shepard, NADD Nationally Ranked Superior DUI Attorney, Former ASA — 14th Judicial Circuit, Shepard Law

Theft crimes in Bay County, Florida, and an overview of theft charges under Florida law.

Legally reviewed by:
Rusty Shepard, Founding Attorney, Shepard Law, LLC

If you are facing criminal charges in Florida, at some point you will likely be asked to consider a plea deal. Understanding what a plea bargain is, how it works, and whether it is in your best interests is one of the most important decisions you will make in your case.

As a former Assistant State Attorney, Rusty Shepard has been on both sides of plea negotiations. He has offered plea deals as a prosecutor — and negotiated them on behalf of clients as a defense attorney. That dual perspective is invaluable when it comes to advising clients on whether to accept, reject, or counter a plea offer.

What Is a Plea Bargain?

A plea bargain is an agreement between the defendant and the prosecution in which the defendant agrees to plead guilty (or no contest) to a charge in exchange for some benefit from the State. That benefit typically takes one of three forms:

  • Charge bargaining — the prosecution agrees to reduce the charge to a less serious offense (for example, from a felony to a misdemeanor, or from aggravated battery to simple battery)
  • Sentence bargaining — the defendant pleads guilty to the charged offense in exchange for a specific, agreed sentence, avoiding the risk of a harsher sentence at trial
  • Count bargaining — in multi-count cases, the prosecution agrees to dismiss some counts in exchange for a guilty plea on others

The Advantages of Accepting a Plea Deal

  • Certainty — a plea deal gives you a known outcome. A trial involves risk, and an unfavorable verdict can result in a significantly harsher sentence than the plea offer
  • Reduced charges — a skilled attorney can negotiate a felony down to a misdemeanor, dramatically reducing the impact on your record, your employment, and your rights
  • Reduced sentence — even pleading to the same charge, a negotiated sentence may be far more favorable than what a judge might impose after a trial conviction
  • Speed — plea resolutions are faster than trials, reducing the time your case hangs over your life
  • Diversion programs — in some cases, particularly for first-time offenders, a plea agreement may include a diversion program that results in the charge being dismissed upon completion
  • Reduced cost — trials are expensive and time-consuming. A plea resolution can significantly reduce the overall cost of your defense

The Disadvantages of Accepting a Plea Deal

  • Permanent record — a guilty or no contest plea results in a criminal conviction on your record. In Florida, most convictions cannot be expunged or sealed
  • Collateral consequences — a conviction triggers consequences beyond the sentence: professional license risk, immigration impact, loss of firearms rights, and employment barriers
  • Waiving your right to trial — by accepting a plea, you give up the right to have the State prove its case beyond a reasonable doubt, the right to confront witnesses, and the right to appeal most issues
  • Pressure — plea deals often come with deadlines. You should never feel rushed into a decision of this magnitude without thorough legal advice
  • The State’s case may be weaker than it looks — an experienced defense attorney may identify weaknesses in the evidence, procedural violations, or credibility issues that could result in a far better outcome at trial than the plea offer

How Rusty Shepard Evaluates a Plea Offer

Every plea offer requires a thorough analysis of:

  • The strength of the State’s evidence — what can actually be proved at trial?
  • The weaknesses in the State’s case — suppression issues, witness credibility, procedural errors
  • The realistic range of outcomes at trial — what does a conviction look like, and what does an acquittal look like?
  • The collateral consequences of a conviction — beyond the sentence, what does a guilty plea actually mean for your life?
  • Your personal circumstances and goals — some clients prioritise avoiding a felony record above all else; others would rather fight for an acquittal

A plea deal is never a default — it is a strategic choice made after fully understanding your options. Shepard Law prepares every case as if it is going to trial, because that preparation is what gives us the leverage to negotiate the best possible plea — and the credibility to walk away from one that is not in your interest.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I change my plea after I have entered it?

In limited circumstances, yes. A motion to withdraw a plea must be filed before sentencing, or after sentencing on grounds of manifest injustice. This is a narrow and difficult motion. It is far better to make the right decision before entering a plea than to try to undo it afterwards.

Does taking a plea mean I am admitting guilt?

A guilty plea is an admission of guilt. A no contest (nolo contendere) plea is not technically an admission of guilt but is treated as one for sentencing purposes and results in a conviction. The distinction matters primarily in the context of civil liability — a no contest plea cannot be used as an admission in a subsequent civil lawsuit.

What if I am innocent — should I still consider a plea?

This is the hardest question in criminal defense. Rusty Shepard’s view is that the decision must be made based on the realistic risk of conviction at trial and the consequences of that conviction, not on principle alone. An innocent person who faces a credible risk of a 10-year sentence at trial and is offered probation through a plea is in a different position from an innocent person with a strong defense and weak State evidence. Every case requires an honest, experience-based assessment.

Facing a plea offer in a criminal case? Call Shepard Law at (850) 290-2505 before you decide anything. Free consultation. Available 24/7.